Paper to MTGO

To sell us your paper singles for Magic Online credit you will need to create a buylist on our other website

You can add cards to your buylist by either searching for them by name or browsing for them by set. Once you are done adding cards to the buylist you just click checkout. At checkout make sure you select to be paid in PayPal and in the notes you put "for credits".

Once we receive your cards and grade them you will receive a gift certificate via e-mail to for the total of the buylist which includes the 20% extra over the cash value.

If you have any questions make sure to scroll down on the buylist page @CapeFearGames to see if your question is answered there and if not feel free to give us a call at 910-798-6006.

Search our Site
Advanced Search